I picked this up a few weeks ago when my L'Oreal Micellar Solution had ran out as I'd heard good things about the Garnier Micellar Water and thought I'd give it a go. I paid £4.99 for the bottle which is pretty good as it's double the size of the L'Oreal version for the exact same price.
For starters, I definitely prefer the packaging of this one as the dispenser is more controlled and I don't waste any product when I tip it up to use it which is an issue I had with the L'Oreal version. It is fairly bulky but I quite like the pink theme so I don't mind it taking up a little more space on my dressing table.
Despite the ingredients for both the L'Oreal and Garnier Micellar waters being the same, I am leaning towards the Garnier one as my favourite. I'm not sure why I feel there's a difference, but it seems like there's less residue on my skin after using the Garnier one and my skin feels more thoroughly cleansed too.
It's hypoallergenic so it doesn't irritate or dry my skin out after using it and when I go over my skin with my toner afterwards, it has done a good job of removing all of my makeup so if I'm feeling lazy at night, I don't worry too much if I don't use any products afterwards.
The only negative I have found is that it isn't great at removing stubborn eye makeup. If I have only a little bit of mascara and eyeliner on then it can deal with it but if I've gone for a more smokey or heavy look, I'm left with serious panda eyes in the morning so I've been using my Nivea Eye Makeup Remover for the days when I've gone to town on my eyes.
Overall, I'm pleased that I purchased it and I enjoy using it as a quick way to remove my makeup in the evening. The bottle says you'll get 200 uses from it and I've not been keeping count but it already feels like it's lasting me longer comparatively than the L'Oreal version which seemed to go down really quick.
I'm not sure I'd repurchase it immediately after it runs out, I'd quite like to try out other products first and maybe give the Micellar waters a break for a bit but don't hold me to that!